25
Legalizing Gay Marriage
Alright ya’ll, it’s business time. I promised yesterday to do a series on somethings that I believe that definitely set me apart for the stereotypical Christian. Please prayerfully consider my thoughts and see what God leads you to do.
Again, here’s my list:
1. Skipping church doesn’t mean you’re going to hell.
2. Gay people should legally be allowed to get married.
3. Drinking beer or wine is not a sin.
4. Masturbation is not a sin.
5. “Secular” music is not from the devil.
6. Not everyone in church is a Christian.
7. I don’t think the world is going to end in my lifetime.
This is NOT a permission slip to go out and do all these things- read all week to get what I’m getting at!
I’m going to start with number 2, since it’s obviously the heaviest topic, and the one that I’ve already received the most criticism about. I’m sure I’ll get some pretty angry responses, that’s okay- I’m past the point of taking in personally!
I’ve already taken so much flack for this one. I totally understand why. I think by this point in time, each and every one of use knows someone who considers themselves gay. It’s a raging debate in a lot of churches. Whole denominations are making stands on this issue that are blowing apart their congregations.
I think this is a very important issue to discuss, but not a very easy one to put to rest.
Before I jump into this though, we need to set the record straight:
1. Stop assuming gay people can’t be in love. We cannot deny the fact that gay people do love each other- deeply and intimately.
2. Stop assuming gay people are animals. Legalizing homosexuality doesn’t mean that ‘next week they’ll all be screwing animals.’ That’s gross, and highly offensive to me and everyone else I know, gay or straight. Stop thinking so unconsciously.
3. You can be ‘gay’ and love Jesus. It’s not the attraction that’s the sin. It’s the action. There are people in your church who believe they’re gay, but are choosing to live holy lives in massive faith. Do not put these people down. Support them as much as you can. They are heroes, they are fellow soldiers, and they are co-workers in building God’s kingdom.
Alright, here it is…
I think LEGALLY, gay people should be allowed to be married.
There, I said it. If my country put it to a vote, and the majority chose this, then so be it. We can’t assume that church and state are the same. We cannot deny their rights.
First thing people bring up:
Well then they’ll force pastors to marry gay people. Heck no. That’s a violation of my rights, and I’d never do it.
But they could take away your pastoral credentials or tax benefits if you refused to marry gays! Oh really? You need credentials to do ministry? Do you serve God for the tax credit?!
Here’s an idea: government could sign a ‘Gay Marriage Act’. This way, ministers could take the course and get licensed to marry gay people. Those opposed simply wouldn’t take the course, therefore would be unable to marriage gay people. That wasn’t so hard was it?
But Jay, legalizing homosexuality will break down society!
And society isn’t already breaking down?! You need to realize that this world is coming to an end. We’re on a sinking ship, and our job is the rescue as many as possible. Stop blaming gay people for ruining the world, and start to change the world instead.
Christians, listen up: If someone doesn’t know Jesus, it is NOT up to the church to dictate morality. My mom always said, “you can’t clean a fish until you catch him!” (and it’s God’s job to clean my heart and life anyway.) People will continue to sin, and heavy-handed judgement is the last thing we need to do as Christ-followers. So let’s start by cutting that out.
Secondly, and much more importantly- (Christians, we truly need to wrap our heads around this) just because something’s legal doesn’t mean it’s right!!!
Seriously, conservative Christians have been battling gay marriage in the courts for soooo long… but does it really matter to the gospel?! Who said legality is the be-all-end-all?
In Canada, you can legally have anal sex with a consenting 14-year-old. Doesn’t mean it’s right. In Canada, you can get off on a rape charge…if you were drunk. Doesn’t mean it’s right. In Canada, you can kidnap and force a girl into prostitution, and get away with a small monetary fine. Doesn’t mean it’s right.
Just because a country gives the green light doesn’t mean God says it’s okay. Being married under the marriage act doesn’t mean you’ve got God’s blessing… gay or straight. That’s a whole nutha level.
Realize that the world and the body of Christ are heading in two completely different directions. It’s not up to us to course-correct legislation. It’s up to us to change minds, present the gospel, and support the life-changing power of Jesus in the lives of those we’re loving and serving. (DANG…that was good.)
Okay, let’s go WAY beyond legalization…
Here’s my greatest concern about this issue: there’s a generation of Christians being raised that, because of their love for their gay friends, are accepting homosexual behavoiur as okay. What’s happening is that they’re ignoring/throwing out/tip-toe-ing around what God says is sin in order to continue to care for those they SO deeply love.
You don’t have to ignore God’s commands in order to love gay people. Or straight people for that matter. I’ve got a bunch of supposed ‘Christian’ friends who I’d love to punch in the teeth. But my commend from God is simple: love them. But not their sin.
Let me be very clear. God loves every single person he ever created.
But He does not condone their every single action, choice, habit, or lifestyle.
This includes me- God HATES my sin. He created me for more- for a life lived in Him.
1 Corinthians 6:9-10 is SO clear:
Don’t you realize that those who do wrong will not inherit the Kingdom of God? Don’t fool yourselves. Those who indulge in sexual sin, or who worship idols, or commit adultery, or are male prostitutes, or practice homosexuality, or are thieves, or greedy people, or drunkards, or are abusive, or cheat people—none of these will inherit the Kingdom of God.
Christians- do not deny sin as sin. See all mankind for who they are- broken, sinful, hurting people in need of a Lord and Saviour. And then be like Jesus to them.
So what should we the church being doing about the whole gay issue?
I think there’s a LIST of things that Christians could be doing when it comes to the ‘gay issue.’ None of them involve gay bashing, putting others down, or shunning people with a different sexual orientation.
1. Stop the hypocrisy.
We’re SO quick to pick ‘GAY’ out of that passage. But we forget what God is talking about here: ALL sin- sexual sin, worship idols (like MONEY), commit adultery (before, during, or after marriage, people!), male prostitutes, thieves (including corporations and those who take advantage of others), or greedy people (who won’t even tithe maybe?), or drunkards (uh oh college kids), or are abusive (or just downright mean), or cheat people (this includes not helping the poor.)
If you’re a sinner, you’re just as sinful as a gay person. Don’t hide behind your goodness or religion or discipline. We’ve all sinned. We’ve all fallen short. We need to fess up. And stop pretending we’re perfect.
2. Stop dictating morals.
God didn’t say “be good.” And he certainly didn’t say “force others to be good.” He said, “Love the Lord YOUR God with all your heart, soul, mind, and strength.“ Do that, and your goodness will PERMEATE the lives of others.
3. Realize that the gay lifestyle isn’t a very open and holistic way to live.
My wife took a class in university with a gay section. First day in the section…everyone sits down…the teacher knows Michelle is a Christian. So he singles her out: “Michelle, what do you think of homosexuality?” Trying to make her look bad…but forgot she had the Holy Spirit. And He came through big time. I believe God spoke through Michelle…and it floored both her and silenced her professor.
“I think it’s sad that we live in a world where we base our identity solely on who we have sex with.”
So true Michelle. The biggest ‘gay issue’ is that it commodifies a person- that we are who we have sex with. “Hi, I’m Jay and I have sex with a woman named Michelle.” It takes the humanity out of the description and the equation. No job, family, hopes, dreams, ambitions, hobbies, goals, vision, adventure, fun. Just who we sleep with. It’s so narrow and close-minded and shallow. That’s the real issue here.
4. Address the hurt.
If the church focused on helping people receive healing- from past relationships, abuse, lack of good parenting, failures, hurt, broken dreams, others who’s condemned them….if the church focused on a restoration of humanity- we’d be much further along in being the hands and feet of Jesus to the gay community.
5. Lead towards Jesus with love.
1 Corinthians 6:11 gives us such hope:
Some of you were once like that. But you were cleansed; you were made holy; you were made right with God by calling on the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God.
Tell your story. We were all once in sin of some kind. Tell your ‘Exodus story.’ About where you came from, the long hard journey, and the Promised Land.
Gay bashing and hating? A sure-fire way to ostracize an entire community of people.
Offering hope and the possibility of redemption? Now that’s a game-changer.
Jay







August 25th, 2009 at 4:40 pm
Wow, I disagree with your interpretations of the bible(or simply those who wrote the one you read) but for the rest of your article, you sir, are truly Blessed by God.
I’m not here to get into a discussion on “What the bible really says” blah blah blah, since it could take us nowhere after a long time, I just wanted to commend you and congratulate you on being honest and looking at the whole picture instead of picking up a pitchfork and screaming. You rock.
August 25th, 2009 at 5:31 pm
This was really well-done Jay. One of my best friends is a lesbian, and we’ve had a few conversations along this line (and I’m sure we’ll have more in the future). It’s nice to see I’m not alone among Christians.
There are a few things in the post that I would question. The first is #4 on your confession list, that masturbation is not a sin. I do actually agree with you in theory, but I’d make a conservative estimate that 99.9% of masturbation involves lust, which very clearly is a sin (Matthew 5:28). So that’s a claim you’d have to explain very carefully.
The second is #2 on your list of how to handle the “gay issue”. You say that God never told us “be good”. Three years ago I might have agreed with this, but then a friend of mine showed me Matthew 5:48 - “Be perfect, therefore, as your heavenly Father is perfect.” The context is about loving our enemies; Jesus is telling us that our righteousness (love in this case) must surpass what the world would expect of us.
Lastly, I like your point with #3 on the list of how Christians should deal with the gay community. Identifying oneself simply as gay or lesbian is very one-dimensional. But I don’t know many gay or lesbian people who do so. Take my friend I mentioned earlier: she’s a big fan of NCAA basketball, she absolutely loves her university, she’s been involved in student leadership since she got here, she’s a big West Wing junkie, and she wants to work in education, likely in government somewhere. Oh, and she likes women. And I doubt she’d tell you that any one of these things really defines her. I guess I would suggest this as an alternate to #3: “Don’t accept the idea that a sexual orientation completely defines someone.” Anyone who does buy into that, gay or straight, is really missing out on life.
August 25th, 2009 at 8:37 pm
Excellent points, Jay. The Bible says all sin is equal in God’s eyes, but I don’t see churches rallying in protest of people who rob convenience stores?
August 25th, 2009 at 10:08 pm
Jay, so glad you’re opening up this dialogue. I think it’s one that needs to happen far more openly and in a widespread way. So thanks!
I have one thought/question - you’ve said that a gay lifestyle is not a”very open or holistic” way to live - which I think is true of a particular subsection of the homosexual community. In the same way that Michelle drew the issue out to a broader scope, I think we need to be careful to not assign generalities to all those who identify as homosexual - or to limit characteristics to those who do. What I mean is, not everyone who identifies as gay makes their sexuality the only basis of their identity. In the same way, many, many heterosexual people find their primary identity in their sexuality. I think it’s dangerous to find your primary identity in your sexuality, whether gay or straight. It’s not holistic to live that way…but that doesn’t mean that all (or only) homosexuals do.
Does that make sense? And thanks again for sharing your thoughts here.
August 26th, 2009 at 4:50 pm
Lol…yup. Or fat people. It’s all about the heart eh?
August 26th, 2009 at 4:54 pm
Well John, you’re jumping the gunning on the masturbation conversation! Patience friend
Matthew 5:48 is impossible for humans to achieve- by themselves. Aiming solely for this negates the need for grace and Christ’s sacrifice- (”not by works which we have done…”) It takes ‘Spirit strength’ to lead a righteous life. You could be sin-free, but not loving. You could be pure, but not sacrificing. Perfection isn’t the goal- Christlikeness is. And that’s wayyy more holistic!
August 26th, 2009 at 4:55 pm
Lol…thanks Joey. I’d encourage you to read my post a few days back about Biblical accuracy. I’d bet my life on it.
I’m wondering what exactly in my interpretation you disagree with? Curious. Thanks for reading dude.
August 26th, 2009 at 5:23 pm
Hey Beth,
I totally agree…I just don’t get my words across as well as I should. Totally agree. Thanks for reading Beth, I love your stuff!